Food

What's New

7 Shipshewana Holiday Events That Will Dazzle You!

by Laurie Sherck For me, the holidays in Shipshewana is the most wonderful time of the year.    This year is no exception. Please...

The ABCs of Amish Schools

By Marcia Eichhorn Prior to moving to Shipshewana to build my home and operate Bright Morning Star Bed and Breakfast, I taught 4th...

Part 4 of 12 Amazing Things To Do in Shipshewana

by Laurie Sherck I've known Shipshewana all my life and it is shear pleasure for me to share with you what I find so special and...

More News

Upcoming Events

Home Free- A Country Christmas

Wednesday, December 12, 2018, 8:00pm
Home Free is bringing new music, new production, more country and holiday favorites as they come to town in "A Country Christmas Tour"! The 5-man band has become known for their show-stopping...

Shipshewana's Lights of Joy Drive-Thru

Thursday, December 13, 2018, 6:00pm
Shipshewana will become home to more than two million LED Christmas lights displayed in a mile-long symphony of various light scenes this holiday season. Shipshewana’s Lights of Joy, a drive-through...

Glory & Majesty of Christmas

Thursday, December 13, 2018, 7:00pm
The 10th Annual Glory and Majesty of Christmas A living Christmas card that tells the story at the heart of the season. Make your plans once again this year with family and friends and...

More Events

pinAttractionspinLodging pinFoodpinShoppingpinFestivalspinServices

Find the best places to eat in Shipshewana, IN.   Whether you are looking for an Amish cooked meal, a fine restaurant dining experience, a cafe or take out pizza, we've got you covered in Shipshewana.  Shipshewana has a reputation for great food!

  • Amy's Pizza, LLC
    Come relax in a family atmosphere at a local family restaurant located next to the Van Buren Hotel. We have hot subs, pizza, appetizers and ice cream novelties for dine-in, carry out or delivery. Hours: Tues throughThurs 11am-7pm Friday and Saturday 11am-8pm. 140 E. Country Lane, Shipshewana, IN 46565.
  • Aunt Millie's Candy & Nut Shop
    Third floor Davis Mercantile Shipshewana's famous candy store, featuring locally made Butter Caramels, Peanut Brittle, Nutty Crunch and Caramel Corn. Discover licorice from around the world, Jelly Belly, Salt Water Taffy, Giant Swirl Lollipops, Feather pops from the Chief, seasoned pretzels, novelty treats and outrageously fun kids candy. Facebook: Aunt Millie's Candy Store. Monday through Saturday, 10am to 5pm., 225 Harrison St., Shipshewana, IN
  • Ben's Pretzels
    It's L-O-V-E at first bite. We've been told our Amish-Inspired, Jumbo Soft Pretzels are legendary and who are we to argue? Our dough is made fresh, on-site, daily and hand rolled. Give our scrumptious Pretzel pockets, Pretzel Dogs or Buggy Bites a try. Our pretzels are far from ordinary, they're preservative free, and our secret ingredient is LOVE. 260-768-4939 Open Monday-Saturday 10am-5pm. Closed Sundays. Located at 100 E. Berkshire Dr., Shipshewana, IN 46565.
  • Blue Gate Restaurant and Bakery
    BLUE GATE RESTAURANT When you visit the Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, you will enjoy a warm and inviting atmosphere, great home-style cooking, friendly service and all the baked goods your heart desires. While your table is being prepared, enjoy a peaceful moment on one of the many gliders that line our beautiful wrap-around porch. If there is a wait, feel free to shop around in any of the Riegsecker Family shops. Our shops are all equipped with the same paging system, so you can hear your name paged when your table is ready, no matter where you are in the Marketplace. 195 North Van Buren St., Shipshewana, IN 46565. 260-768-4725.
  • Buggy Lane Tours
    Enjoy buggy rides, visit an Amish working dairy farm, and experience delicious Amish Cooking In-Home dining in the heart of beautiful Northern Indiana-Amish/Mennonite Country! Located at The Boardwalk in Shipshewana, Buggy Lane Tours has been helping our customers build memories since 1985. Join us on a guided tour where you will see whitewashed houses, golden corn fields, laundry blowing in the breeze, amazing flower gardens and the occasional stand selling homemade baked goods and home grown veggies. Before you leave for home, be sure to stop by the Boardwalk Café for delicious homemade ice cream and bag of freshly popped kettle corn. Call John 574-333-9584.
  • E&S Sales
    Largest selection of bulk foods in the area! Stock up on bulk flours, candies, nuts, snacks, dried fruits, baking ingredients and spices! We offer cheeses, meats, fresh produce, jams & jellies, salsas and many other products. We make and sell our own delicious noodles and take & bake pizzas. We have an in-house bakery and sandwich/ice cream shop. Check out our antiques on display as you shop the store. Open Monday through Friday 7:30am to 5:30pm; Saturday 7:30am to 4pm. Located at 1265 N. SR 5, Shipshewana, IN 46565.
  • East of Chicago
    Open 7 days! Lunch and dinner buffet with pizza, subs, salad bar and more at family friendly prices. Delivery and carry out also available. Located at 350 S. Van Buren Ste C., Shipshewana, IN 46565 260-768-7272.
  • Hoosier Banquets
    Come sit at our table and we will serve you a home cooked meal, family style. Later we will join you for coffee and dessert and some good old round the table conversation. You may ask us any questions about our Amish way of living and our heritage. Call us for a reservation-we would be glad to have you. 260-336-8533. Ray and Linda Miller, located at 6335 W 200 N, Shipshewana, IN
  • JoJo's Pretzels
    Located inside the Davis Mercantile Famous for our hand-rolled soft pretzels, JoJo's is a 'must experience' on your visit. Warm, fresh pretzels in a variety of flavors and home made mustard are the perfect treat! 205 N. Harrison St., Shipshewana, IN
  • Kitchen Cupboard
    Located inside the Davis Mercantile Fruit smoothies, espressos, cappuccinos, and coffees. Locally roasted coffee beans, gourmet foods, salsas and JoJo's mustard. Free samples daily! Hours: 9am - 6pm Memorial Day - December; 9am - 5pm Winter. 205 Harrison St., Shipshewana, IN 46565
  • Millie's Market Café
    Located on the 3rd floor of the Davis Mercantile Meet at the Market, Shipshewana's lunchtime destination! Serving tasty sandwiches & wraps, delectable salads, soups bursting with flavor, hand scooped ice cream and freshly baked pies. Featuring our Country Cobb Salad, Orchard Chicken and season fries. Experience house made freshness a Millie's Market Cafe! Seasonal rooftop dining available! Hours 11am-3:30pm Monday-Saturday 255 E. Main St., 3rd Floor, Shipshewana, IN
  • Next Door Neighbor Deli & Bakery
    Country bakery including jumbo cinnamon rolls, pies, muffins, cookies, and brownies. Home of "Fruitcakes by Deb" and "Cashew Butter Bars". Breakfast and lunch menu. Dine inside or on our covered porch. Or, call ahead for box lunches to go. Phone 574-825-1716. Hours Monday-Friday 6:00 a.m. - 2:00 p.m. Saturday 6:00 a.m. - 1:00 p.m.
  • Pumpkinvine Café and Catering
    Stop into the Cafe for our delicious sandwiches, soups, breakfast items and specialty coffees. Have a pizza delivered, discover our many mouth-watering flavors of cheesecake, or try our BBQ ribs on Friday and Saturday nights! Catering services are available for gatherings small and large, including business lunches, weddings, etc. Open 8am-8pm, Monday-Saturday. 230 N. Morton St., Shipshewana, IN
  • Red Bud Gift Shop & Café
    Yoder's Red Barn Shoppes Enjoy lunch with us! Try our Red Bud specialty sandwich, homemade soup and apple dumpling. Sip your favorite tea served from a hand-decorated China Tea Pot and served with your choice of a muffin or scone. We carry hand decorated china teapots & more, 50+ kinds of teas, flavored coffee, and 30 kinds of fudge, soft-served and hand-dipped ice cream and also hand-dipped chocolate candies. 260.768.3013 We also take orders for our famous fruitcake during the holiday season. Hours: 9am to 5pm Monday through Saturday. Located in Yoder's Red Barn Shoppes, 2nd Floor, 461 S. Van Buren St., Shipshewana, IN 46565
  • Shipshe Pizza and Mini Golf, Inc.
    Enjoy a "loaded" fresh made pizza or hoagie and sides. Eat-in our clean, cozy dining room. Finish with a round of mini-golf. Carry-out and delivery available. Hours 11am-8pm, Tuesday-Saturday. Flexible hours for large orders. 260-768-8060.
  • Victorian Candy Company
    457 S. Van Buren St., Shipshewana, IN 46565 The Victorian Candy Company began making their famous Brittle Brackle candy from an Old Amish Recipe in 2009. Our nostalgic Victorian styled store is nestled within Yoder's Red Barn Shoppes. Sample our made-on-site Brittle Brackle, or some of our other delectable products: gourmet coffee, spiced apple cider, fudge and dips. We have Old Fashioned Candy to satisfy kids of all ages. Open Monday-Saturday, 10am-5pm. 260-768-3272
  • Wana Cup
    Generations have been raised on frosted glasses of homemade root beer, pizza burgers and Friday night fish at the Wana Cup. Conveniently located between downtown and the Flea Market, the Wana Cup is a true Shipshewana blend of fast food paired with home-baked desserts. Breakfast, lunch and dinner prepared the way you like it. Choose from a daily special or from our sandwich menu. Winter Hours: Mon-Thurs 7am-7pm; Fri-Sat 7am-8pm. Located at 295 S. Van Buren St. (SR 5), Shipshewana, IN.
  • Yoder Popcorn, LLC
    Come enjoy a free sample of freshly made popcorn while you browse around our cozy shop for all your popcorn needs. We carry 8 varieties of popcorn including our famous Tiny Tender(R)! Located 3 miles South of Shipshewana. Hours: Jan-Feb-March: Monday-Saturday 10am-4pm; April thru Dec: Monday-Friday 9am-5pm, Saturdays 9am-4pm. Closed Sundays. Toll-free: 800.892.2170, Located at 7680W 200S, Topeka, IN 46571
  • Yoder's Homestyle Cooking, LLC
    Celebrating our 17th year of offering family dining on our Amish farm. Enjoy a Thresher's Meal, Haystack, light lunch, or breakfast. Relax before and after your meal by enjoying the beautiful scenery and fresh country air. Your delicious meal will be served in our plainly decorated dining room overlooking a lovely lake view. Cooking classes available. 260-768-3078, Located at 10667W 523N, Shipshewana.
  • Yoder's Meat & Cheese Co., Inc.
    Taste the Difference that is wholesome goodness from the farm! We provide naturally fed with no added growth hormones or steroids Beef, Buffalo, Pork and Chicken. Browse our Hickory Wood Smoked Meats, all made in house. We offer 80 varieties of cheese and gourmet specialty foods at affordable prices. Open year around: Monday-Saturday 8:00am-5:30pm Saturday 8:00am-5:00pm. Closed Sundays, Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's Day. Winter hours subject to change. Located at 435 S. Van Buren St. (SR 5), Shipshewana, IN 46565. 260-768-4715.